Tag Archives: armour

Plate Mail: D&D Myth? – Medieval Weaponry and Accoutrements

Mixed cuir bouilli plate and lamellar

Mixed cuir bouilli plate and lamellar

If you’ve ever played Dungeons & Dragons, you are familiar with plate mail. If not, all you really need to know is that it is basically the best armour you can buy, short of magically enhanced protection. Well, at least, it used to be. Then at some point they introduced ‘full plate mail’.

But wait! Plate. Mail. Is it plate, or is it mail? How can it be both?

If you poke around the internet a bit, you’ll come across the general notion that plate mail is a total D&D fabrication and historically inaccurate. I’ve even seen forum debates on this topic. You had plate armour, which was what we all have in our heads when we think of knights in shining armour, and you had mail, which tended to comprise of interlocking rings of iron, or similar.

Nothing really springs to mind in connection with plate mail (although D&Ders might find themselves assigning this language to plate armour, by default). The Baldur’s Gate wiki tells me this:

Plate mail is a combination of chain armor with metal plates covering the vital areas such as the chest, abdomen and groin. Similar in construction to bronze plate mail, true plate mail comprises chain and leather.”

Full plate mail is the best armor a warrior can buy, both in appearance and protection. The perfect fitted interlocking plates are specially angled to deflect arrows and blows and the entire suit is carefully adorned with rich engravings and embossed details.”

Well. We have two kinds of armour, both of which use the word ‘mail’, and only one of which is described as actually including mail…

I’m going to say that ‘full plate mail’ was actually just full plate, which was worn over mail, but of which the full plate was not, in any sense of the word, a type of mail.

As for ‘plate mail’… It turns out that there actually was a kind of armour for which ‘plate mail’ is a fairly accurate description, and the Baldur’s Gate wiki description is pretty darn good.

Basically it works like this. Armour is layered. Mail is one of those layers (with a few layers underneath). If you were wealthy, full plate was your top layer. But what about the poor sods who weren’t so wealthy? You know, the common soldiers.

Brigandine

Brigandine

Turns out there were other kinds of plate besides full plate, including a lot of stuff made out of ‘cuir bouilli’ – or boiled leather. It was almost as hard as iron. You had brigandines, which was leather lined with cuir bouilli or iron plate. You had lamellar, which was a kind of scaled armour – basically cuir bouilli or iron scales attached to a coat. You also had articulated cuir bouilli plate – think full plate, but made out of boiled leather. You might dismiss this as ‘leather armour’ (the poorest form of armour in D&D) but it was really hard. Really hard. You also had odds and ends of iron plate used in conjunction with all this other stuff – basically pieces of iron plate that did not amount to a full suit.

So what do you have if you throw a brigandine or lamellar over mail and toss in some articulated cuir bouilli or iron plate? Well, layers, obviously. More layers than you had before. But you also have a pretty good mix of mail and plate, which at the same time is not full plate. Or as the wiki says, a combination of chain armour with plate protecting the vital areas…

Most the research in this post was done for my upcoming novel In the Company of the Dead and drew from a post by Joseph Malik – you can find his posts on armour here and here. Don’t assume the pictures I’ve used here are good examples of armour – they are just to demonstrate the different types. You should definitely read Joseph’s posts in full.

Klappvisier – Medieval Weaponry and Other Accoutrements

Klappvisier


Welcome to the first in my new monthly series – medieval weaponry and other accoutrements for the historically-minded!

As part of today’s A to Z Challenge post I am featuring the ‘klappvisier’. 

To understand the klappvisier, we must first understand the bascinet – an open-faced military helmet, which extended downwards at the rear and sides to protect the neck. It might attach a mail curtain (camail or aventail) to the lower edge of the helmet to afford greater protection to the throat, neck and shoulders. This aventail might be riveted to the bascinet, or otherwise might be removable.  Eventually the camail was replaced by a gorget made of plate metal, giving rise to the greater bascinet.

Of course, you should immediately spot the problem with the bascinet. For all the protection it afforded the head, neck, throat and shoulders – it was open-faced!

To solve this problem, they designed and attached visors, which existed in many iterations throughout the use of the bascinet. The klappvisier was but one version. Featuring either a pointed or rounded snout to deflect arrows, and a raised area around the eyes, it was used from 1330 – 1340 and onwards. One of the key distinguishing features of the klappvisier was its single hinge in the centre of the brow. 

The klappvisier was used widely in Germany, but also appeared in northern Italy, as it features in a Crucifixion painted in Santa Maria Novella in Florence.

References
Gravett, Christopher (2008) Knight: Noble Warrior of England 1200-1600. Osprey Publishing.

Lucchini, Francesco (2011) Face, Counterface, Counterfeit. The Lost Silver Visage of the Reliquary of St. Anthony’s Jawbone. Published in Meaning in Motion. Semantics of Movement in Medieval Art and Architecture, edited by N. Zchomelidse and G. Freni. Princeton.

Viollet-le-Duc, Eugène Emmanuel (1874). “Bascinet”. Encyclopaedia Dictionnaire raisonné du mobilier français 5. Paris: V. A. Morel. p. 157.


This is an A to Z Challenge post. If you enjoyed this post, please feel free to check out my previous posts if you haven’t already. If you’re finding yourself here often, you might like to join as a member, sign up to the blog through RSS or email, or sign-up to my newsletter. Check out my March Newsletter if you missed it.

Don’t forget to share the love and spread the word on Twitter, Facebook or StumbleUpon (or other social networking site of your choice) if you know other people who might also enjoy this.

Thanks for stopping by and visiting!